The Part B Penalty Isn't Built on Your IRMAA

"Neil Cain, CFP®, ChFEBC℠ |

The Part B late enrollment penalty is calculated on the standard premium only, never on your IRMAA surcharge. For healthy, high-income federal retirees with good FEHB coverage, that single fact can change the decision about when to enroll.

The fear driving the decision

Many federal retirees keep FEHB and still sign up for Part B at 65, even when their income puts them in a high IRMAA bracket. The reason we hear most often is fear of the penalty. Specifically, people believe that if they wait, the penalty will be stacked on top of their IRMAA-inflated premium for the rest of their lives.

That belief leads some retirees to pay thousands of dollars a year for coverage they rarely use. Here is how the penalty really works, and what the numbers look like for a retiree whose income climbs once Required Minimum Distributions begin.

How the penalty is actually calculated

The penalty is 10% of the standard Part B premium for each full 12-month period you could have had Part B but didn't. Once it applies, you pay it for as long as you have Part B. IRMAA is a separate charge, based on your income from two years earlier, and the penalty is never applied to it.

\text{Monthly cost} = \text{Standard premium} + (\text{Penalty \%} \times \text{Standard premium}) + \text{IRMAA}

Take a retiree who waited 10 years (a 100% penalty) and is in the third IRMAA tier in 2026. Their monthly cost is $202.90 + $202.90 + $324.60 = $730.40. It is not $527.50 doubled, which would be $1,055.

Two FEHB-specific points matter here. First, FEHB as a retiree is not coverage from current employment, so it does not qualify you for a penalty-free Special Enrollment Period. Second, FEHB counts as creditable drug coverage, so keeping it means no Part D penalty if you ever move to a Part D plan.

2026 Part B premiums by IRMAA tier

Whatever your tier, each 10% of penalty adds the same $20.29 a month in 2026.

Tier

2024 MAGI, single

2024 MAGI, joint

Monthly Part B premium

IRMAA portion

Standard

$109,000 or less

$218,000 or less

$202.90

$0

1

$109,001–$137,000

$218,001–$274,000

$284.10

$81.20

2

$137,001–$171,000

$274,001–$342,000

$405.80

$202.90

3

$171,001–$205,000

$342,001–$410,000

$527.50

$324.60

4

$205,001–$499,999

$410,001–$749,999

$649.20

$446.30

5

$500,000 or more

$750,000 or more

$689.90

$487.00

Sources: MOAA, Yahoo Finance, summarizing CMS 2026 figures.

Case study: a retiree pushed into tier 3 by RMDs

In this hypothetical, waiting until 75 comes out ahead for Tom until about age 87. After that, enrolling at 65 would have been cheaper.

Tom is a single retired federal employee, 65 in 2026, covered by FEHB Self Only. He was born in 1961, so his RMDs start at 75. From 65 to 74, his FERS pension plus Social Security put his MAGI around $150,000, which is tier 2. At 75, TSP and IRA RMDs push it to about $185,000, which is tier 3.

He compares two paths. Path A: enroll in Part B at 65. Path B: rely on FEHB alone, then enroll at 75 with a 100% penalty. The figures below are for Tom alone, start from 2026 premiums, and assume premiums rise 4.2% a year, their average over the last 20 years.

Tom

Path A: enroll at 65

Path B: enroll at 75

 

Monthly premium at 65

$405.80

$0

 

Total paid, ages 65–74

$59,010

$0

 

Monthly premium at 75

$795.98

$1,102.14

 

Penalty cost in the first year (it keeps rising)

$0

$3,674

 

Total paid by 90 (15 years of penalty)

$253,137

$268,797

 

Total paid by 95 (20 years of penalty)

$349,417

$402,110

 

Path B keeps $59,010 in Tom's pocket during the first ten years. By 90, though, enrolling at 65 would have cost him $15,660 less. Both paths pay the same tier 3 IRMAA after 75, so the growing penalty is the only thing the delay costs him. For a married couple where both spouses face the same choice, roughly double these figures.

A rule of thumb, and what the myth costs

In today's dollars, the number of years it takes the penalty to catch up with your savings is 10 times your premium multiple during the years you wait. Rising premiums shorten that, so the chart assumes 4.2% annual growth. Each year you wait saves a full year of premiums but adds a penalty of only 10% of the standard premium.

Computed from 2026 CMS Part B premiums · Part B delayed from 65 to 75, per person

Computed from 2026 CMS Part B premiums · Part B delayed from 65 to 75, per person

Now compare what Tom would conclude if he believed the penalty applied to his tier 3 premium. In 2026 dollars, that version adds $6,330 a year instead of $2,434.80. With 4.2% growth, it makes waiting look like a losing bet by about age 80, when the real break-even is about 87. The myth makes each year of penalty look more than two and a half times as expensive as it is.

What the math leaves out

The numbers above compare premiums only. They leave out what Part B actually buys you, and other assumptions can move the answer. Weigh these before deciding.

  • Premium inflation. These examples assume premiums rise 4.2% a year, the standard premium's average over the last 20 years, from $88.50 in 2006 (CMS) to $202.90 in 2026. The last decade ran closer to 5%, which would pull Tom's break-even to about 86. The examples also assume Tom's savings earn nothing while he waits. If he invests them and earns 4%, break-even moves out to about age 94, and at 5% to about 97. At 5%, his savings would grow to about $73,000 by 75, and about $48,000 would still be left at 90 after paying every penalty. Investment returns aren't guaranteed, though.
  • Bad years come out of your nest egg. Without Part B, FEHB pays first and you pay its cost sharing up to the plan's yearly out-of-pocket maximum. For 2026 Self Only coverage, that in-network cap is $6,000 on FEP Blue Standard and $7,500 on FEP Blue Basic (FEP Blue), and other plans run higher. Tom saves about $4,870 a year by waiting in 2026, so one bad year at the cap can wipe out more than a year of savings, paid straight from his retirement accounts. With Part B, many FEHB plans waive most of that cost sharing.
  • Bigger balances, bigger premiums. The more you have in your TSP and IRAs, the larger your RMDs and the higher your IRMAA tier. That's what pushed Tom into tier 3. A larger nest egg makes Part B more expensive to carry, so the decision belongs in your tax and withdrawal plan, not just your health plan.
  • You can't enroll the moment you need it. Outside a Special Enrollment Period, you can sign up only from January 1 to March 31, and coverage starts the month after. A diagnosis in April means most of a year on FEHB alone.
  • Postal and military retirees. Under the Postal Service Health Benefits Program, many postal annuitants must be enrolled in Part B to keep their coverage. Military retirees must have Part B to keep TRICARE through TRICARE For Life. For both groups, this choice may not be open.
  • Each spouse decides separately. The math is per person, and health can differ between spouses.

More than a dollar difference

Part B also changes what's covered and how easily you get care. It covers wheelchairs, hospital beds, oxygen, prosthetic limbs and braces that some FEHB plans cover only in part (FedWeek). It lets you see any provider that takes Medicare nationwide, with few prior authorizations and no hard cap on therapy visits. And you need it to join the Medicare Advantage options several FEHB carriers offer, some of which reimburse part of the Part B premium. A single serious illness or injury can make these the deciding factor.

Who might consider waiting

Delaying Part B can make sense if you are in good health, in tier 2 or higher, happy with your FEHB plan and its network, and planning for income that will stay high. It makes less sense if you have ongoing health needs, are near the standard bracket, are a postal annuitant covered by the PSHB rule, are a military retiree who wants to keep TRICARE, or want a plan that pays you back for enrolling in Part B.

The point is not that everyone should skip Part B. It's that the penalty should be weighed for what it is, a charge on the standard premium, rather than the much larger number many people fear. A Capital Financial Planners advisor can run these numbers against your own pension, Social Security, RMD projections and FEHB plan.

Disclosures

The case study is a hypothetical illustration for educational purposes and does not represent any actual client. Premium figures start from 2026 amounts published by CMS. Projections assume 4.2% annual premium growth and are not guarantees. This article is not individual advice; consult your advisor about your own situation.

Securities offered through LPL Financial, Member FINRA/SIPC. Advisory services offered through Capital Financial Planners, LLC, a registered investment advisor. Capital Financial Planners and LPL Financial are separate entities.